Analysis: So we now find out that it was indeed the unverified and Fak...

8y ago Jul 23, 2018 at 2:30 PM

So we now find out that it was indeed the unverified and Fake Dirty Dossier, that was paid for by Crooked Hillary Clinton and the DNC, that was knowingly &amp, falsely submitted to FISA and which was responsible for starting the totally conflicted and discredited Mueller Witch Hunt!

0:00 0:00

AI Analysis

Machine-generated analysis of the post above on 2026-03-15. Not written by the author of the post.

Danger Level

None

Narcissistic State

Grandiose

Authorship

Self-Written

Intensity

64%

Posted at 10:30 AM EDT on July 23, 2018, two days after DOJ released the heavily redacted Carter Page FISA warrant applications, this post represents a reactive conversion of ambiguous new evidence into totalizing vindication narrative. Authorship is assessed as likely authentic (confidence: medium), driven by the '&amp,' HTML encoding artifact — a technical error an aide would have corrected — combined with stream-of-consciousness syntax and reflexive use of stock epithets. The psychological driver is narcissistic injury deflection: the FISA release sustained media focus on the Russia investigation, threatening to extend the threat to Trump's self-narrative. His response reframes the investigation's entire legitimacy through a falsified causal chain (Dossier → FISA → Mueller), converting an ongoing, productive legal process into proof of his victimization. Paranoid features are prominent throughout — the entire investigative apparatus is recast as a fabricated conspiracy. The grandiose state is maintained via certainty performance ('we now find out'), which forecloses epistemic doubt. Defense mechanisms: denial (labeling the investigation 'discredited' while it was actively producing convictions), projection (attributing 'knowing and false' deception to opponents), and rationalization (constructing a simplified causal narrative). The gaslighting element is structural: the post preempts audience engagement with independent evidence by asserting the investigation's illegitimacy as settled fact. No danger indicators are present. This post is clinically representative of Trump's established defensive posture toward the Mueller investigation rather than a marked deviation from baseline.

Authorship Analysis

Self-Written

Indicators:

'&amp,' is an unescaped HTML entity — a raw encoding artifact that an aide would almost certainly have caught before posting, strongly suggesting direct composition in a web UI
Stream-of-consciousness single-sentence run-on structure spanning the entire post
Stock Trump epithets ('Crooked Hillary,' 'Witch Hunt') deployed reflexively
Emotional urgency: 'So we now find out' — reactive framing typical of authentic posts responding to breaking news
10:30 AM EDT falls within business hours, a mild aide indicator, but does not override the encoding artifact and stylistic markers

Psychological Profile

▶ State

Grandiose State

Trigger: Narcissistic Injury — Exposure (DOJ release of Carter Page FISA warrant applications (July 21, 2018), which despite being redacted provided adversaries evidence to critique FBI conduct but also renewed media scrutiny of the Mueller investigation's origins)

Rage: Intensity 62% targeting Mueller investigation, Hillary Clinton, DNC, FBI

Proportionality

35%

Sentiment

-0.72

▶ Clinical

Malignant Narcissism:

Narcissistic

78%

Antisocial

42%

Paranoid

71%

Sadism

25%

Defense Mechanisms:

projectiondenialrationalizationsplitting

Cognitive Complexity:

Complexity

31%

Cognitive Markers:

perseveration

Parasocial Techniques:

'So we now find out' — inclusive plural creates shared discovery experience with followers, positioning them as fellow investigators uncovering the truthLabeling system ('Crooked,' 'Fake,' 'Witch Hunt') functions as tribal identity markers, signaling in-group membership through shared vocabularyCertainty framing transforms contested interpretation into established fact, rewarding followers who accept the narrative

Danger Assessment

None

Gaslighting Detected:

'We now find out' performs false discovery — converts a partisan interpretation of a redacted document into established fact
Describes an ongoing, productive investigation with multiple convictions as 'discredited' — attacks audience's ability to assess the investigation's legitimacy on its own terms
Causal chain (Dossier = cause of Mueller) is presented with certainty, preempting alternative framings that audiences might otherwise encounter in news coverage

Reality Distortions:

Mueller investigation characterized as 'discredited' while actively producing convictions and guilty pleas
FISA dossier framed as the singular originating cause of the entire Russia investigation, erasing the Papadopoulos thread, Comey firing, and Rosenstein's appointment memo
'Knowingly and falsely submitted' asserts proven criminal intent where investigators found procedural errors but no demonstrated intent to deceive

Fact Checks (4)

"The Steele Dossier was paid for by Crooked Hillary Clinton and the DNC"

Mostly True

The Steele Dossier (formally 'Company Reports') was commissioned by Fusion GPS, which was retained by law firm Perkins Coie on behalf of the Clinton campaign and DNC. This funding chain is documented. 'Paid for by' is a simplification that omits the layered contracting structure and the fact that the research was initially funded by a Republican donor before the Clinton campaign took over funding.

"The dossier was 'knowingly and falsely submitted' to the FISA court"

Mostly False

The DOJ Inspector General (December 2019) found 17 significant errors and omissions in FISA applications but concluded the investigation was properly predicated and found no evidence of intentional fraud or politically motivated decisions. 'Knowingly false' implies criminal intent that has not been established. FISA Court subsequently criticized the FBI for the errors.

"The dossier 'was responsible for starting the Mueller Witch Hunt'"

Mostly False

Special Counsel Mueller was appointed on May 17, 2017, by Deputy AG Rosenstein following Trump's firing of FBI Director Comey. The Steele Dossier was one element in a broader counterintelligence investigation (Crossfire Hurricane) that predated the dossier and was triggered by George Papadopoulos's disclosure to an Australian diplomat. The FISA warrant was for Carter Page, not the initiating cause of the Mueller appointment.

"The Mueller investigation is 'totally conflicted and discredited'"

False

At time of posting (July 2018), the Mueller investigation had already produced guilty pleas from Michael Flynn, George Papadopoulos, Rick Gates, and Alex van der Zwaan, and indictments of 13 Russian nationals for election interference. The investigation was active and producing legal results. 'Discredited' is an assertion unsupported by any judicial or institutional finding at this date.

Receipts

No contradictions with other posts detected yet.

Psychological Analysis: July 23, 2018 — FISA / Dossier / Mueller Post

Authorship Attribution

Score: 0.78 (likely authentic) | Confidence: Medium

The decisive indicator is the &, encoding artifact embedded mid-sentence. This is a raw HTML entity that was never decoded — the kind of error that occurs when composing directly in a web interface that submits literal HTML markup. A communications aide reviewing before posting would almost certainly have caught and corrected this before publishing. The comma immediately following the entity (&,) is a secondary error consistent with hasty, unreviewed composition.

Supporting authenticity: single-sentence run-on structure spanning the entire post; reflexive deployment of stock epithets ("Crooked Hillary," "Witch Hunt"); reactive "So we now find out" framing consistent with impulsive response to breaking news. The 10:30 AM EDT timing is within business hours (a mild aide indicator) but is outweighed by the above.

Triggering Event

The Carter Page FISA warrant applications were released by DOJ on July 21, 2018 — two days before this post. The 400+ page redacted document provided partisan critics material to attack FBI conduct, but it also renewed intensive media coverage of the investigation's origins. Trump's post is a direct reactive conversion of that ambiguous new evidence into an unambiguous exoneration narrative.

This is a textbook narcissistic injury deflection: a threat to the subject's self-narrative is met not with defensive retreat but with offensive counter-framing that reconstitutes the threat as proof of victimization.

Psychological State

Narcissistic state: Grandiose — no vulnerability or retreat is present. The post is entirely offensive in posture, characterized by certainty and forward attack rather than wounded defensiveness.

Trigger type: Narcissistic injury (exposure/renewed scrutiny)

The FISA release threatened to prolong media focus on the investigation. Rather than absorbing or ignoring this, the post attempts to seize the evidence and redirect its meaning. "We now find out" performs discovery — it positions Trump as the revelatory figure who has been proven right all along.

Rage: Present at moderate intensity (0.62/1.0). The hostility is diffuse across multiple targets (Clinton, DNC, Mueller, FBI) rather than focused. Proportionality is low (0.35) — the response is disproportionate to any concrete new information in the FISA release. The release confirmed that the dossier was used in FISA applications (already known), but did not, as claimed, establish knowing or intentional fraud.

Defense Mechanisms

Mechanism	Level	Evidence
Denial	Pathological	Describes an investigation with multiple convictions and guilty pleas as "totally discredited" — refuses external reality
Projection	Immature	Attributes "knowing and false" submission of fabricated documents to opponents — the accusation of deliberate deception mirrors Trump's own documented pattern of making false claims
Splitting	Immature	Perfect binary: Crooked Hillary/DNC/discredited Mueller vs. implicitly innocent Trump; no gray zone acknowledged
Rationalization	Neurotic	Constructs linear causal narrative (Dossier → FISA → Mueller) to neutralize the investigation's legitimacy through origin story

Multi-Level Personality Analysis (McAdams & Pals)

Level 1: Dispositional Traits

Dominant facets:

N2 (Angry Hostility): High. Post is structured entirely around resentment toward named enemies.
A1 (Trust, inverse): Very low. Blanket suspicion of the investigative apparatus, media, and political adversaries.
E1 (Assertiveness): High. Confident, declarative, no hedging.
O5 (Values rigidity): High. No openness to alternative interpretations of the FISA evidence.

Level 2: Characteristic Adaptations

Dominant motive: Power/agency (0.88). Communion is near-absent. The post is entirely oriented around control of narrative, neutralization of a legal threat, and assertion of dominance over perceived adversaries.

Operative schema: "I am being systematically targeted by a coordinated conspiracy, and evidence of that conspiracy is now emerging." This is a closed, self-confirming schema — any new development is interpretable as further confirmation of the conspiracy.

Level 3: Narrative Identity

Protagonist role: Victimized truth-teller / counter-punching exposer of a rigged system
Narrative sequence: Contamination — a victory or moment of peace (presidency, relationship with Putin, NK progress) is being poisoned/contaminated by a fabricated investigation
Identity claims: "I have been set up," "the truth is now coming out," "the investigators were the criminals"
Contrasting other: Hillary Clinton and the DNC — the paradigm case of rule-bending and institutional corruption that Trump defines himself against

Level 4: Clinical Indicators

Malignant narcissism component scores:

Narcissistic features: 0.78 (grandiosity, entitlement, lack of perspective-taking)
Paranoid features: 0.71 (preoccupation with attacks, conviction of coordinated persecution)
Antisocial features: 0.42 (contempt for legal process, framing investigators as criminals)
Sadistic features: 0.25 (mild delight in labeling opponents; not a primary feature of this post)

Rhetorical Analysis

Primary technique: Narrative hijacking. The FISA release, which contained genuinely ambiguous information about FBI conduct, is seized and converted into a totalizing exoneration narrative. The move from "FBI made errors in FISA applications" to "the whole investigation was fabricated and criminal" requires several logical leaps, but the post performs them as if they were self-evident.

"So we now find out" is the load-bearing phrase. It performs three simultaneous functions:

Creates temporal urgency (this is new information)
Asserts certainty (the finding is settled, not interpretation)
Deploys inclusive plural (reader is co-discoverer, implicated in the revelation)

Propaganda techniques active in this post:

RAND Firehose component: This is post #4 or #5 on July 23 alone, targeting Amazon/WaPo, North Korea critics, Putin summit critics, Carter Page/FBI, and now the dossier/Mueller. Volume normalization — the audience becomes habituated to the attack posture.
Whataboutism: Russia investigation deflected to Clinton/DNC conduct.
Epistemic pre-emption: "Totally discredited" forecloses independent audience evaluation.

Gaslighting Assessment

Present. The post employs three gaslighting moves:

False discovery: "We now find out" converts contested partisan interpretation into settled revelation
Legitimacy erasure: "Totally discredited" instructs the audience to dismiss the investigation before engaging with its findings
Causal compression: Reducing the investigation's origins to a single fabricated document erases the Papadopoulos thread, Comey firing, and Rosenstein's appointment memo — requiring the audience to unknow these established facts

Fact Verification

Claim	Verdict	Evidence
"The Steele Dossier was paid for by Crooked Hillary Clinton and the DNC"	Mostly True	The Steele Dossier (formally 'Company Reports') was commissioned by Fusion GPS, which was retained by law firm Perkins Coie on behalf of the Clinton campaign and DNC. This funding chain is documented. 'Paid for by' is a simplification that omits the layered contracting structure and the fact that the research was initially funded by a Republican donor before the Clinton campaign took over funding.
"The dossier was 'knowingly and falsely submitted' to the FISA court"	Mostly False	The DOJ Inspector General (December 2019) found 17 significant errors and omissions in FISA applications but concluded the investigation was properly predicated and found no evidence of intentional fraud or politically motivated decisions. 'Knowingly false' implies criminal intent that has not been established. FISA Court subsequently criticized the FBI for the errors.
"The dossier 'was responsible for starting the Mueller Witch Hunt'"	Mostly False	Special Counsel Mueller was appointed on May 17, 2017, by Deputy AG Rosenstein following Trump's firing of FBI Director Comey. The Steele Dossier was one element in a broader counterintelligence investigation (Crossfire Hurricane) that predated the dossier and was triggered by George Papadopoulos's disclosure to an Australian diplomat. The FISA warrant was for Carter Page, not the initiating cause of the Mueller appointment.
"The Mueller investigation is 'totally conflicted and discredited'"	False	At time of posting (July 2018), the Mueller investigation had already produced guilty pleas from Michael Flynn, George Papadopoulos, Rick Gates, and Alex van der Zwaan, and indictments of 13 Russian nationals for election interference. The investigation was active and producing legal results. 'Discredited' is an assertion unsupported by any judicial or institutional finding at this date.

Overall Veracity: 30%

Archetypal Analysis

Primary archetypes: Warrior + Victim (oscillating)

The post cycles rapidly: Warrior (attacking enemies, exposing conspiracy) and Victim (targeted by fabricated investigation). This oscillation is structurally important — it allows the subject to simultaneously claim persecution and dominance without resolving the contradiction. The Warrior justifies aggression; the Victim justifies grievance. Together they produce a closed loop that no external evidence can disrupt.

The Shadow projection is explicit: the accusation of "knowingly and falsely" submitting fabricated documents to law enforcement is precisely the accusation that adversaries level at Trump. What is disowned about the self is attributed wholesale to opponents.

Order/Chaos dynamics: Trump positions himself as an Order Restorer whose legitimate order (his presidency) is being disrupted by a corrupt pseudo-Order (the investigative apparatus). The rhetorical move is to delegitimize the existing institutional order as itself chaotic/criminal, making chaos-introduction the restorative act.

Cognitive Assessment

No deviation from baseline detected. Single-sentence run-on structure, stacked modifiers, and formulaic epithets are consistent with Trump's documented Twitter baseline for this period. The &, error is a platform artifact, not a speech production marker. Perseveration on "Witch Hunt" (also appears in the Carter Page quote post on the same day) is mild and within normal range for Trump's established repetition patterns.

Danger Assessment: None

No eliminationist language, dehumanization, violent imagery, or stochastic terrorism indicators. This is political grievance rhetoric with no direct threat vectors.