Analysis: #CHANGETHELAWS Now is the best opportunity ever for Congre...

8y ago Jun 19, 2018 at 2:11 PM

#CHANGETHELAWS Now is the best opportunity ever for Congress to change the ridiculous and obsolete laws on immigration. Get it done, always keeping in mind that we must have strong border security.

0:00 0:00

AI Analysis

Machine-generated analysis of the post above on 2026-03-15. Not written by the author of the post.

Danger Level

Elevated

Narcissistic State

Grandiose

Authorship

Uncertain

Intensity

48%

Posted at peak backlash from ProPublica's viral audio of detained children crying in a CBP facility, this tweet is the culminating entry in a five-post immigration blitz on June 19, 2018. Its primary psychological function is DARVO (Deny, Attack, Reverse Victim and Offender): the Trump administration's own zero-tolerance executive policy — enacted via an April 2018 AG Sessions memo and fully reversible by executive order — is reframed as an inevitable consequence of 'ridiculous and obsolete' Congressional laws. This gaslighting is clinically notable because Trump signed an executive order the following day ostensibly ending separations, revealing retrospectively that the 'laws made me do it' framing was false. The hashtag (#CHANGETHELAWS) and imperative 'Get it done' deploy grandiose-instrumental framing: a humanitarian crisis is converted into a dealmaking opportunity. Business hours timing and strategic hashtag suggest aide involvement or collaborative authorship, distinguishing this from Trump's more impulsive late-night posts. Evaluated in cluster context alongside the same-day 'infest our Country, like MS-13' tweet — which applied dehumanizing language to undocumented immigrants broadly — the full sequence represents a coordinated messaging operation combining dehumanization (cluster level) and responsibility deflection (this post). Cognitive markers are within established baseline. Danger level elevated at cluster level due to dehumanizing language in adjacent posts; this specific tweet registers none.

Authorship Analysis

Uncertain

Indicators:

10:11 AM EDT — business hours, within aide-written range
Strategic hashtag (#CHANGETHELAWS) suggests staff coordination
Clean grammar and complete sentence structure
'Ridiculous and obsolete,' 'Get it done,' and superlative 'best opportunity ever' are Trumpian constructions
Consistent with collaborative/lightly-edited aide draft

Psychological Profile

▶ State

Grandiose State

Trigger: Narcissistic Injury — Exposure (ProPublica audio of detained children; UN Human Rights Council condemnation; international backlash over family separation policy)

Sentiment

-0.22

Mildly Hypomanic

Five-plus immigration tweets in rapid succession on a single dayEscalating rhetoric across cluster (crime statistics → border → infestation → legislative urgency)Mobilization framing and hashtag activism suggesting elevated arousal stateUrgency manufacturing ('best opportunity ever') consistent with mild pressure-response elevation

▶ Clinical

Malignant Narcissism:

Narcissistic

62%

Antisocial

32%

Paranoid

18%

Sadism

12%

Defense Mechanisms:

rationalizationdenialdisplacement

Cognitive Complexity:

Complexity

44%

Parasocial Techniques:

Hashtag-based mobilization (#CHANGETHELAWS) activates base as political actorsImperative 'Get it done' creates sense of shared missionUrgency framing ('best opportunity ever') induces FOMO-style compliance

Danger Assessment

Elevated

Indicators:

Cluster-level dehumanization: same-day tweet applying 'infest' and MS-13 association to undocumented immigrants broadly
Stochastic terrorism triad partially present in cluster: target (undocumented immigrants/Democrats) + grievance (infestation/crime) + implied action (Congress must act, We must arrest)
Mobilization hashtag converts passive followers into political pressure actors
False framing that only legislative change can end crisis may justify continued policy harm in follower interpretation

Gaslighting Detected:

DARVO at national scale: administration's zero-tolerance executive policy reframed as statutory legal compulsion requiring Congressional remedy
Implicit denial of executive agency — Trump had full authority to end separations by executive order (demonstrated June 20)
Attribution shift from executive policy to 'obsolete laws' erases the causal chain of the family separation crisis
Epistemic closure: followers accepting this frame are insulated from accurate accountability assignment

Reality Distortions:

Family separation policy attributed to statutory legal obligation rather than discretionary executive zero-tolerance memo (April 2018)
'Best opportunity ever' framing erases the humanitarian emergency created by the administration's own policy
Congress framed as the necessary agent of change for a crisis the executive branch created and could unilaterally end

Fact Checks (3)

"Immigration laws are 'ridiculous and obsolete' and forced family separations"

Mostly False

Family separations resulted directly from the Trump administration's April 2018 'zero tolerance' executive policy directive from AG Sessions, not from statutory law. The Flores Settlement Agreement (1997) actually constrained unlimited child detention. Trump signed an EO on June 20 ostensibly ending separations, confirming executive discretion was available throughout.

"This is 'the best opportunity ever' for Congress to change immigration laws"

Unverifiable

Subjective political judgment about legislative opportunity; not falsifiable.

"We must have strong border security"

Unverifiable

Normative policy assertion, not an empirical claim subject to fact-checking.

Receipts

No contradictions with other posts detected yet.

Analysis: #CHANGETHELAWS — June 19, 2018

Authorship Attribution

UTC 14:11:51 → 10:11 AM EDT (Washington, D.C.) — Trump was in Washington this week for the National Space Council meeting (Space Force announcement) and managing the family separation political crisis. Business hours post.

Stylistic markers are mixed: the strategic hashtag (#CHANGETHELAWS) and clean grammatical construction point toward aide involvement; however "ridiculous and obsolete," "Get it done," and the superlative "best opportunity ever" are characteristic Trumpian constructions. Assessment: collaborative/aide-assisted, likely drafted or lightly cleaned by staff but reflecting Trump's intended message and voice. Confidence: medium.

Contextual Frame

This tweet is the fifth in a rapid-fire immigration messaging cluster on June 19, read in sequence:

IG report → "Rigged Witch Hunt"
German migrant crime statistics
"If you don't have Borders, you don't have a Country!"
Democrats want illegals to "infest" the country like MS-13
[This post] #CHANGETHELAWS — Congress must act

The posting cluster arrives at peak public blowback from ProPublica's viral audio of Central American children crying in detention. The UN Human Rights Council had just condemned the policy. The sequence reveals a coordinated defensive messaging operation.

Psychological Analysis

Trigger

Classic narcissistic injury exposure: the family separation policy — an executive choice enacted via the April 2018 Sessions "zero tolerance" memo — was generating intense public revulsion and international condemnation. This post deploys textbook DARVO (Deny, Attack, Reverse Victim and Offender): the crisis is reframed as a legal inevitability requiring Congressional remedy. The administration's agency is erased.

Narcissistic State

Grandiose-maintenance mode. "Best opportunity ever" is characteristic superlative inflation even within a defensive posture. This post lacks the raw narcissistic injury signals present in same-day tweets (no victimization language, no grievance enumeration). The grandiosity is instrumental — framing a crisis as an opportunity positions Trump as dealmaker rather than perpetrator.

Defense Mechanisms

Rationalization (neurotic): "Ridiculous and obsolete laws" converts an executive policy choice into a systemic legal failure, providing post-hoc logical cover for the separations.
Displacement (immature): The object of criticism (Trump's zero-tolerance directive) is displaced onto Congress and existing statutory law.
Denial (pathological): Implicit erasure of the administration's direct agency. The zero-tolerance policy was entirely reversible by executive memo — as Trump demonstrated weeks later when he signed an executive order ostensibly ending separations.

Narcissistic Dynamics

Trigger type: Narcissistic injury (exposure of policy cruelty)
Rage: Absent in this specific post; the cluster as a whole shows displaced aggression toward Democrats and migrants
Supply-seeking: Secondary — the hashtag functions as a mobilization tool for the base
Preemptive attack: The narrative shift to Congressional incompetence preempts sustained accountability

Personality (Multi-Level Framework)

Level 1: Dispositional Traits

Extraversion (high): Assertive imperative mood ("Get it done"), directive tone
Agreeableness (low): Zero concession or acknowledgment of suffering; instrumental framing throughout
Conscientiousness (moderate): Goal-directed, on-message — but the goal is narrative management, not policy deliberation
Neuroticism (moderate-low for this tweet): Controlled compared to same-day "infest" post; the hashtag campaign suggests calculated affect management
Openness (low): "Obsolete laws" implies rigid, closed framing — the only solution is enforcement expansion

Level 2: Characteristic Adaptations

Agency motive dominant: Power and control are the organizing schemas. Congress is cast as a tool to be deployed ("Get it done"), not a co-equal branch.
Achievement framing: "Best opportunity ever" converts crisis into potential win
World schema: Threats are external, chaos is others' fault, solutions require Trump's initiative

Level 3: Narrative Identity

Protagonist role: Order-restorer / deal-closer — stepping in to fix a broken system
Redemption arc: Broken laws (contamination) → Trump-driven legislative fix (redemption)
Identity claims: "I am the only one who sees the opportunity"; "I am the border security champion"
Contrasting other: Feckless Congress, specifically Democrats ("they don't care about crime" — from cluster tweet #4)

Rhetorical Analysis

Hashtag mobilization: #CHANGETHELAWS functions as a marching order, transforming followers into political actors
Superlative framing: "Best opportunity ever" — characteristic hyperbolic urgency
Imperative voice: "Get it done" — projects executive authority onto legislative branch, performs dominance
False framing / gaslighting: The framing that laws require family separation is factually false; this is the core rhetorical move of the cluster
False dichotomy (implicit): Strong border security OR humanitarian treatment — no middle ground offered
Order-restorer positioning: The "chaos" of illegal immigration is attributed to legislative failure; Trump offers himself as the restorer
Whataboutism (cluster-level): German crime statistics and MS-13 deflect from detained children narrative
No dehumanizing language in this specific tweet (contrast with "infest" tweet earlier)

Fact Verification

Claim	Verdict	Evidence
"Immigration laws are 'ridiculous and obsolete' and forced family separations"	Mostly False	Family separations resulted directly from the Trump administration's April 2018 'zero tolerance' executive policy directive from AG Sessions, not from statutory law. The Flores Settlement Agreement (1997) actually constrained unlimited child detention. Trump signed an EO on June 20 ostensibly ending separations, confirming executive discretion was available throughout.
"This is 'the best opportunity ever' for Congress to change immigration laws"	Unverifiable	Subjective political judgment about legislative opportunity; not falsifiable.
"We must have strong border security"	Unverifiable	Normative policy assertion, not an empirical claim subject to fact-checking.

Overall Veracity: 40%

Gaslighting Indicators

DARVO executed at national scale: The administration's own policy is attributed to external legal compulsion
Epistemic closure mechanism: Followers who accept the "obsolete laws" frame cannot assign responsibility to the administration
Rapid revisionism: Trump would sign an EO the following day contradicting the implicit premise that only Congressional action could end separations — confirming the executive had the power all along

Danger Assessment

This specific post: none — policy advocacy language, no targeting, no eliminationist framing.

Cluster-level (same-day posts): elevated — the "infest our Country, like MS-13" tweet constitutes dehumanizing language applied to an entire demographic group. Associating all undocumented immigrants with MS-13 is a classic out-group dehumanization technique with documented links to stochastic terrorism dynamics. The sequence (target: immigrants; grievance: infestation; implied action: Congress must act) maps onto the first two legs of the stochastic terrorism triad.

Cognitive Status

Within baseline for this period. Sentence structure is coherent, logical flow is intact (if factually misleading), vocabulary is consistent with established Trump register. The hashtag capitalization is a stylistic convention, not a cognitive marker. No deviation from baseline detected.

Hypomanic Indicators

The volume of same-day immigration tweets (5+ in a short window), the escalating rhetoric across the cluster, and the mobilization framing suggest a mildly elevated arousal state — consistent with defensive urgency in response to the ProPublica audio and UN criticism. Not outside Trump's documented response range to acute political pressure.